Appraisal:  What is appraisal?  What is bias?

As often happens, failure to agree on the disagreement – the question – is the real disagreement. Darn!

This is why I insist on defining topic words, lest our personal meaning-bias get in the way of our understanding-bias.

An appraisal is an opinion of value.  (It used to be an “estimate” of value.)  The measure of appraisal is to be credible – “worthy of belief.”  Worthiness is a bit hard to quantify, but reviewers (under review standard 3 of USPAP) form a worthy opinion of the worthiness of the appraisal believability.

Of Bias we have differentiated two types:  Analytic bias, or personal bias.

Analytic bias may come from:  1) wrong or inadequate data; 2) subjective adjustments or predictive algorithms; or 3) erroneous interpretation or explanation.

Personal bias may be conscious, unconscious, or social (the result of “groupthink”).

Here I want to explore two other types of bias, stemming from the groupthink concept.

Groupthink bias happens where an idea is collectively followed, even though it is wrong.  In appraisal, an example is the “accepted” idea that 4 or 5 comparables is enough, even as standards require the use of all relevant competitive sales.

Systemic bias is the result of social groupthink transferred to law, or to administrative functions, or even to professional standards.  We have two examples of systemic bias.

The first is the historical reality of “redlining,” based on race or other such distinctions.  Loan redlining became embedded in the law, a criteria for “safe” lending practice.  While this administrative reality was removed some time ago, the many impacts of the policy continue.  Appraisers are the measurers of some of these remnants – not the creators or perpetrators of such discrimination.

The second systemic example is also appraisal-related.  This is a mismatch between the appraiser ‘credibility’ requirement, and appraisal reviewer criteria.  While an appraiser is judged by credibility, defined as “worthy of belief,” the reviewer is judging by different criteria (in Standard 1 of USPAP (Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice).  This is promulgated by the quasi-governmental Appraisal Foundation as “Authorized by Congress”, under the direction of The Appraisal Subcommittee.

Worthiness of belief is difficult to measure.  The review Standard 3 does not attempt to measure believability.  Instead, an appraisal reviewer “is required to develop an opinion as to the completeness, accuracy, adequacy, relevance and reasonableness” of the reviewed appraisal report.

The appraisal must be worthy of belief.  But the reviewer judges it based on the above five words.

This conflict, and these words, are firmly embedded in appraiser education, licensing requirements, user-expectations, personal training methods, conformity to peers’ actions, and of course administrative law in fifty-four state and territories.

Is appraisal biased?  Yes.  It is a matter of groupthink embedded.  Appraisers must follow what is, not what we wish it could be.  Systemic.

I suspect that individual appraisers have little opportunity or inclination to be personal-biased, other than in subtle or overt responses to lender, borrower, and AMC need to make loans.

At Valuemetrics.info, we teach Evidence Based Valuation(c) using Data Science and Artificial Intelligence to measure markets, not compare comps. Classes forming for 2027.